| Term | President |
| 1941 | *William L. Dawe |
| 1942 | Charles Reid |
| 1943 | Edward C. First, Jr. |
| 19445 | Harry Mayer, Jr. |
| 1945 | Richard E. Chaddock |
| 1946 | Ellis Carver |
| 1947 | *Clinton Miller |
| 1948 | *Jay S. Rupert, Jr. |
| 1949 | Robert H. Marshall |
| 1950 | James B. Tyler |
| 1951 | Robert L. Clements |
| 1952 | *George A. Reece |
| 1953 | *James T. Chandler, III |
| 1954 | *J. Richard Cook |
| 1955 | Raymond L. Becker |
| 1956 | *Gerald J. Nixon |
| 1957 | *Robert W. Kramer, Jr. |
| 1958 | *Charles F. Daley, Jr. |
| 1959 | James L. Termine/Richard D. Bennett |
| 1960 | *Joseph P. Wortz |
| 1961 | Richard C. Cecil |
| 1962 | Joseph F. Cook, Jr. |
| 1963 | Ellis Rowland |
| 1964 | *Richard H. Gorman |
| 1965 | Thomas W. Gittins, Jr. |
| 1966 | *Frank T. Wharton |
| 1967 | *Arthur F. DeSabitino |
| 1968 | Ronald H. Curry |
| 1969 | F. Edmund Lynch |
| 1970 | *Robert Marvel |
| 1971 | Lawrence Early |
| 1972 | *Charles Kulp |
| 1973 | *Richard Schliem |
| 1974 | E. Thomas McDonald |
| 1975 | David L. Feasel |
| 1976 | William F. Ward, Jr. |
| 1977 | Stephan C. French |
| 1978 | Lawrence D. Green |
| 1979 | Frank A. Simko |
| 1980 | P. Kim Cloud |
| 1981 | James R. Leonard |
| 1982 | Wayne A. Hyatt |
| 1983 | Robert S. Prost |
| 1984 | Richard Pierce |
| 1985 | Theodore Foschi |
| 1986 | Carole L. (Cloud) Harlan |
| 1987 | David R. Parag |
| 1988 | Bonnie (Krug) Noszek |
| 1989 | David MacKenzie |
| 1990 | Ann Harrison |
| 1991 | Winn Abbott |
| 1992 | Colleen Clark-Ostafy |
| 1993 | N. Lee Dotson |
| 1994 | N. Lee Dotson |
| 1995 | Gerald O’Rourke |
| 1996 | Karen Poore |
| 1997 | Stephen Price |
| 1998 | James C. Shehan |
| 1999 | Darren Wright |
| 2000 | Mark A. Oller |
| 2001 | Lisa Marie Shaw |
| 2002 | Carole Schneider |
| 2003 | Steve Bufflap |
| 2004 | Angela Massey |
| 2005 | Corie (Reeves) Glenn |
| 2006 | Elaine McDonald |
| 2007 | Ameerah Shah |
| 2008 | Jill Henebry |
| 2009 | Abbie Uhler |
| 2010 | Janet Dougherty |
| 2011 | Damian Baccarella |
| 2012 | Laura Crozier |
| 2013 | Alex Mili |
| 2014 | *Donnie White |
| 2015 | Duncan Holyoke |
| 2016 | Kelly Supranowitz |
| 2017 | Kristofer Williamson |
| 2018 | Julianne Shockley |
| 2019 | Sola Aladesanmi |
| 2020 | Josh Hoveln |
| 2021 | Josh Hoveln |
| 2022 | Alice Stevens |
| 2023 | Samar Kargbo |
*Deceased
Wilmington JCI Jaycees - A Community Organization 